November 19, 2026
A listing sheet usually has a short line about heat. It might say "Heat: oil, hot water baseboard," or "gas forced air," or "heat pump." Most buyers skip past it on the way to the photos. This winter in the Lewisburg area, that line could separate two similar houses more than a modest gap in asking price does.
That's because of how this part of the Susquehanna Valley heats its homes. In Census Bureau estimates for 2020 through 2024, 28.3% of occupied homes in Union County heated mainly with fuel oil or kerosene, compared with 14.0% statewide. Over the same period, 11.1% of Union County homes used utility gas, compared with 51.3% across Pennsylvania. So a house here is about twice as likely as the average Pennsylvania house to burn oil, and oil's price climbed far more than any other heating fuel's this fall.
The mix changes once you cross the borough line. The American Community Survey's house heating fuel table breaks it down for Lewisburg borough and the three townships around it. These are 2020 to 2024 five-year estimates. For places this small the margins of error are wide, so read the figures as approximate.
| Area, ACS 2020–2024 | Utility gas | Electricity | Fuel oil/kerosene | Propane |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lewisburg borough | 32.8% | 37.0% | 19.3% | 5.6% |
| Kelly Township | 17.0% | 42.1% | 17.4% | 18.5% |
| East Buffalo Township | 12.7% | 58.3% | 22.6% | 2.4% |
| Buffalo Township | 11.6% | 37.2% | 24.4% | 7.2% |
| Union County | 11.1% | 39.3% | 28.3% | 8.4% |
| Pennsylvania | 51.3% | 25.3% | 14.0% | 5.1% |
The borough has the most gas service in the area, but even there about one home in five heated with oil in those estimates. In East Buffalo Township, most homes heat with electricity and more than a fifth use oil. Kelly Township has the most even split, with propane, oil and gas each near one home in six. Buffalo Township, farther west, leans on oil, and about 5% of its homes heat mainly with wood.
If you're looking at a house in the borough and another a short drive out on the same weekend, there's a fair chance the two use different fuels. We've written before about how the "Lewisburg" market splits across the borough line. The heating fuel follows that same line.
The U.S. Energy Information Administration's weekly survey for the week of November 9, 2026, put Pennsylvania's residential heating oil price at $5.708 a gallon before taxes. That's up $2.277 from the same week a year earlier, or roughly two-thirds. Pennsylvania's residential propane price that week was $3.332 a gallon, up $0.489 from a year earlier.
The agency's 2026–27 Winter Fuels Outlook, published October 6, expects homes heating with oil to see the largest increase in spending this winter. It projects the national average heating oil bill at $2,115 for November through March, up 21%, with the average price up 34% to $5.26 a gallon. EIA ties the increase to lower global refining output, costlier imports, stronger export demand, and low U.S. distillate stocks heading into winter. It also says a warmer forecast for the Northeast partly offsets the higher price.
The other fuels look much calmer in the same outlook. For Northeast households over the same November-to-March window, EIA projects natural gas spending of $879, down 14%. It projects propane at $1,687, down 15%, and electricity at $1,637, down 3%. EIA also notes that wholesale changes for heating oil and propane generally reach retail customers within four to six weeks. That means the price an oil-heated house pays in January depends on markets that are still moving.
Western Pennsylvania has already seen what that looks like. In September, TribLive reported, in a story republished by the Mon Valley Independent, that suppliers were bracing for a difficult winter as the Strait of Hormuz stayed closed. One longtime oil customer there said he usually paid $2 to $2.50 a gallon and was having trouble finding a price below $5.99. The same story cited a projection from the National Energy Assistance Directors Association that heating oil costs could rise more than 30% this winter.
In a county where more than a quarter of homes burn oil, a statewide price story affects a lot of local houses.
Electric heat is the most common heating type in the borough, each of the three townships and Union County in the table above, so the electric bill matters as much as the oil price. Buyers moving in from elsewhere in Pennsylvania often expect PPL. In Lewisburg, the distributor is usually Citizens' Electric Company, formed in 1911. It serves Lewisburg borough and parts of Buffalo, East Buffalo, Kelly and West Buffalo townships. Citizens' is wholly owned by C&T Enterprises, which two rural electric cooperatives, Claverack and Tri-County, own in equal shares. The company says it was the first electric company in Pennsylvania to offer customer choice to all of its customers, in 1996.
Citizens' price is changing too. In an October 22, 2026 filing with the Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission, the company proposed raising its default residential supply rate on December 1 from 13.206 to 14.772 cents per kWh. For a typical residential customer using 500 kWh a month, it estimated a total bill increase of about 7.64%. That's a real increase, but it's much smaller than the change in heating oil.
The natural gas picture is the most stable of the four. UGI's posted residential price to compare was $0.76654 per ccf, effective October 1, 2026. In a May notice about its December 1 purchased gas cost filing, UGI showed a typical 68.7-ccf monthly residential bill rising from $118.53 to $120.99, or 2.1%, if the request is fully approved.
What limits gas is where the pipe runs. UGI's tariff lists Lewisburg borough in its service territory, but only portions of Buffalo, East Buffalo and Kelly townships. Being inside a township that UGI serves doesn't mean a particular road has a main. UGI's gas availability lookup asks for a street address and estimates the distance to the nearest main. On a township property, that lookup tells you more about future heating costs than the township name.
A borough house on UGI gas and a township house with an oil tank in the basement might list close together, and they might seem close on monthly cost after you run the mortgage calculator. This winter, the heating fuel adds a cost difference that the asking price doesn't show. It's a lot like how the tax line on a listing can change after you buy. The heating line just changes faster.
On an oil-heated home, ask the seller for a year or two of delivery records and find out whether they buy on automatic delivery or call for each fill. Find out whether the tank, or a propane tank, is owned or leased. Find out who delivers now. Local suppliers include AEP Oil of Winfield, which serves Lewisburg, Mifflinburg, Sunbury and Milton and has automatic and will-call delivery. Miller's Gas & Oil delivers heating oil across Union, Snyder, Northumberland, Montour and Columbia counties. Beco Propane is based in nearby Mifflinburg. On a heat pump or electric home, find out whether the distributor is Citizens' or PPL, because each company has its own rate. On any township property listed as gas-ready or gas-convertible, run the address through UGI's lookup before you treat that as settled.
If you're selling an oil-heated home this season, have the past year's fuel receipts and the name of your supplier ready when you list. Our seller resources cover how to prepare a listing, and the same kind of preparation applies to utility records.
The fuel and utility figures here are general information with the dates shown, not financial advice. Prices move, so please confirm the costs for any particular property with the utility, the fuel supplier or a qualified professional.
If you're weighing a borough home against one a few miles out, or getting an oil-heated house ready to list this winter, Teresa M Keeley is glad to walk through the heating fuel, the utilities and the questions to ask about each with you. Schedule a consultation, and we'll start with the heating line on the listing sheet.
Teresa delivers a refined and highly personalized approach to Pennsylvania real estate. Her commitment to exceptional service and meaningful relationships creates a seamless experience from start to finish. Discover the difference trusted representation can make.